上海视觉

上海视觉 ›› 2026, Vol. 0 ›› Issue (3): 15-21.

• 视觉与图像研究 • 上一篇    下一篇

疤痕的显形:迪迪-于贝尔曼图像学的精神分析与异质哲学溯源

马嗣瑞, 沈语冰   

  1. 复旦大学, 上海 200433
  • 出版日期:2026-09-20 发布日期:2026-10-26
  • 作者简介:马嗣瑞(1996— ),男,复旦大学哲学博士。研究方向为现当代艺术史与批评。
    沈语冰(1965— ),男,浙江大学文艺学博士,复旦大学哲学学院教授。研究方向为西方现代美学、现代艺术史、艺术理论与艺术批评。

Figuring the Stigma: Psychoanalysis and Heterogeneous Philosophy in the Genealogy of Didi-Huberman’s Iconology

MA Sirui, SHEN Yubing   

  • Online:2026-09-20 Published:2026-10-26

摘要:

迪迪-于贝尔曼的图像学有别于英美“后理论”路径,其方法部分继承瓦尔堡思想,也深受法国理论谱系与写作传统影响。本文以其阐述图像作为“疤痕”及“显形”的核心文本,即《在图像面前》第四章,指出弗洛伊德与巴塔耶构成支撑该论述的两条并行线索,二者共同支撑了症候中“撕裂—复活”的双重逻辑。其一,弗洛伊德的“压抑—回返”机制解释了图像对传统模仿论的超越:图像经由自我损毁而使欲望显形,其运作近于梦的凝缩与移置,借替代形式显露无意识欲望;其二,巴塔耶的“无形式”与“去首”不仅揭示了卑贱与神圣双重极性的并存,也恰与迪迪-于贝尔曼笔下“显形—撕裂”的动态过程相对应。由此,本文尝试为迪迪-于贝尔曼图像学补充精神分析与异质哲学的谱系线索。

关键词: 迪迪-于贝尔曼, 图像学, 症候, 弗洛伊德, 乔治·巴塔耶

Abstract:

Georges Didi-Huberman’s iconology stands apart from the “post-theoretical” approaches of Anglo-American scholarship: his method partly inherits Aby Warburg’s legacy while remaining deeply shaped by the French theoretical genealogy and its writing tradition. Focusing on Chapter 4 of Confronting Images — the central text in which Didi-Huberman articulates the image as “stigma” and its “figuration” — this article argues that Freud and Bataille form two parallel threads underpinning that account, together sustaining the dual logic of rending and resurrection at work in the symptom. First, Freud’s mechanism of repression and return accounts for the image’s move beyond classical mimesis: the image figures desire through self-defacement, operating much as condensation and displacement do in dreams, disclosing unconscious desire in substitute forms. Second, Bataille’s notions of the “formless” (informe) and the “headless” (acéphale) not only reveal the coexistence of the double polarity of the base and the sacred, but also correspond to the dynamic of figuration and rending in Didi-Huberman’s writing. The article thereby adds a psychoanalytic and heterological strand to the genealogy of Didi-Huberman’s iconology.

Key words: Georges Didi-Huberman, Iconology, Symptom, Sigmund Freud, Georges Bataille